BYU Cougars vs Texas Tech Red Raiders is the kind of college football matchup that splits living rooms and group chats. Whenever these two meet, the records get thrown out and the only thing that matters is who walks away with the bragging rights.
Both programs call the Big 12 home, so this isn't just pride on the line — it's conference standing, head-to-head tiebreakers, and a direct say in who plays for a title. Every recruiting cycle, every transfer-portal swing, and every Saturday result feeds the same argument. When the Cougars face the Red Raiders, the debate is never settled for long — last year's result just sets up next year's argument.
Below, BYU Cougars and Texas Tech Red Raiders fans make their cases in real time. Stake your claim, drop your prediction, and talk your trash before kickoff.
You kids today with your RPOs and your Air Raid spread. You don't know what real football is. I was watching some old film from the 1983 season, back when Coach Dykes was still an assistant and we ran the veer option out of the wishbone. We had a quarterback who would take the snap, read the defensive end, and either pitch it to the tailback or keep it himself. There was no throwing the ball 60 times a game. You lined up and you ran the option until the defense proved it could stop it. That was football. That was Texas Tech football before everybody got fancy.
The option offense was beautiful in its simplicity. It was about discipline, timing, and toughness. You had to be able to take a hit and get right back up. You had to execute the mesh point perfectly or you'd get blown up in the backfield. That's where you built character. These portal kids who jump ship the second they don't start would never survive a single practice in the old option system. They'd be crying to their agent after the first spring scrimmage. We didn't need five-star recruits to run the option. We needed tough kids from West Texas who loved football.
Wait so this Brendan Sorsby gambling situation has me thinking about something completely different. Back in the Spike Dykes days we had walk ons who would run through a brick wall for a scholarship and a chance to play on Saturday. Guys who worked the scout team for three years before sniffing the two deep. Now we got quarterbacks getting treatment for gambling addictions and the whole program's future hanging on an NCAA ruling. You think a walk on from the 1995 squad would have been caught ...
You want to know what kills me about this Brendan Sorsby situation? We used to have players who went to the Alamo Bowl and actually remembered the trip. Now we have quarterbacks getting treatment for gambling addictions because the same phones that run the playbook also run DraftKings. I remember when the biggest off-field distraction was whether we could get enough guys to the Independence Bowl without missing final exams. This sport has changed and not for the better.
You watch Texas and Oklahoma leave the Big 12 for the SEC and then watch ESPN rank portal classes and tell me this sport makes any sense anymore. We used to have a conference where you knew who your enemies were and you played them every year. Now it is just a free agent free-...
Just saw that ESPN piece on the five-star recruits and where they're going and I had to sit down. Twenty-one five-star players in this class and you can count on one hand how many are even looking at programs west of the Mississippi that aren't named Oregon or Texas. Back in the late 80s when we had guys like Rodney Allison and the old Southwest Conference days, we didn't have this star ranking nonsense but we knew who could play. We'd go watch a kid from Plainview or Odessa and you could tell in the first quarter if he had it.
Now every single five-star is going to the same six programs and the rest of us are left fighting over portal scraps. Speaking of which, I saw Oklahoma State brougth in FIFTY transfers. Fifty. That's not building a program, that's running a hotel for mercenaries. Eric Morris is a good coach, I remember watching him at that little school up in Canyon when he was tearing it up, but you cannot tell me fifty new guys in one offseason is how you build something lasting. Remember when Coach Spike Dykes would bring in a junior college kid maybe once every other year and we'd act like he was a celebrity? Now it's the entire roster every December.
The portal killed something that mattered. You used to watch a kid grow from a freshman who couldn't find the weight room to a senior who could bench press a truck. You knew their names, you knew their families, you saw them at the United supermarket on 19th Street. Now they're here for eight months and gone. We got a quarterback situation right now that's a complete mess and instead of developing the guys in the building we're scrolling through the portal like it's Amazon. NIL and the portal combined have turned college football into a rental car agency and I'm tired of pretending otherwise.
Watching this draft weekend and seeing all these programs get their guys drafted in the first two rounds, then I look at our spring practice depth chart and I just shake my head. People forget what Spike Dykes built here in the 90s with a bunch of overlooked Texas kids who played four years together and knew the system inside and out. We never had five-star recruiting classes but we had continuity and toughness. Now we are trying to compete with Oregon and Texas in the NIL era where they just buy the ESPN top 100 every year. The new revenue sharing cap at 20.5 million is just going to let the rich programs get richer while we scramble for leftovers. I miss the days when you could build a program on development and loyalty instead of who has the biggest bag.
Saw that ESPN poll about the 2027 draft quarterbacks and not a single mention of our guy. Nobody cares about the QB battle in Lubbock right now. Reminds me of the old Southwest Conference days when we'd roll into Austin with a nobody at quarterback and somehow leave with a win because the kid had grit. These national outlets don't even know who's taking snaps for us until September.
Not a single Red Raider on Mel Kiper's final Big Board. Zero. In the 80s and 90s we might not have had five-star croots either, but we had Gabe Rivera, Zach Thomas, and guys who played with their hair on fire. Now we just watch other teams' draft picks shine while we rebuild...
Just saw Mel Kiper's draft board and not a single Red Raider in the top 150. Not one. Reminds me of the early 2000s when we couldn't get a guy drafted to save our lives until Wes Welker came along and reminded everybody what Lubbock produced. You know what the difference was back then? We reruited kids from small Texas towns who had something to prove. Kids who grew up working on farms and playing three sports. Now we're chasing the same five-star transfers as everybody else and losing the identity that made us dangerous. Coach Spike Dykes would drive his pickup truck to some dusty town in West Texas and find a quarterback nobody else wanted and turn him into a winner. That's how you build a program, not by swiping right on the portal.
Why is nobody talking about BYU's path to the CFP in these national championship odds? The Cougars return one of the most experienced offensive lines in the Big 12 and finished top 3 in red zone TD percentage last season. That formula travels.
Winning a bidding war for a quarterback is the exact opposite of the toughness we used to build in Lubbock. I remember watching Robert Hall and Zebbie Lethridge earn their stripes through spring battles, not by having the highest NIL offer. This whole process feels like buying a mercenary, not developing a leader who will bleed for the program. True grit is forged in competition, not in a bank transfer.
This new spread offense obsession has completely forgotten the beauty of a well-run option. I remember watching the service academies carve up defenses with precision and toughness, somethiing you just don't see anymore. It was about discipline and execution, not just finding the fastest guy in the portal to run a jet sweep. The game has lost an art form.
This new era where you can bring in 50 transfers like Oklahoma State is doing is a complete farce and I will die on this hill. It reminds me of the 2008 team that went 11-2, a group that grew together through adversity, not a bunch of hired guns. What are you even building? There's no program identity, just a collection of jerseys. The portal has turned coaches into used car salesmen and players into free agents with zero allegiance. We used to develop kids like Wes Welker over four years, now if a freshman doesn't start by week three he's gone. This isn't football, it's fantasy football with real people, and it's gutting the soul of the sport. Look at Colorado's 43-man class, it's a circus.
Just saw the Big 12 bold predictions. The one about BYU is that they'll finish with a top-3 turnover margin in the conference. That's the key to winning close games in this league.
Just saw the CBS bold predictions for the Big 12. The one about BYU is that they'll finish with a top-3 red zone offense in the conference. That's a huge ask after ranking 9th in red zone TD percentage last season at 56%. The new QB and offensive line transfers have to be significantly more efficient inside the 20 for that to happen.
Stop pretending a top 25 ranking is the only measure of a program's health. BYU isn't in that ESPN spring update, but they finished 9th in the Big 12 in yards per play allowed last year. That's the real issue, not a list. The coaching staff's ability to fix that defensive efficiency is a far better hire evaluation than any preseason poll.
Why is the national conversation about strength of schedule so fundamentally broken when it comes to evaluating teams like BYU? Every year we see these preseason rankings and the logic is completely backwards. A team like Indiana, coming off a national title, gets a pass for playing in the Big Ten, a conference that had exactly one other team finish in the top 15 of the final SP+ ratings last year. Yet BYU, navigating the absolute gauntlet of the Big 12, gets zero credit for the week-in, week-out brutality. The Big 12 had seven teams finish with 8+ wins last season. Their average SP+ conference rating was higher than the Big Ten's. The data is right there.
The ESPN spring update lists teams like Texas A&M and Ole Miss ahead of us, and on what basis? Their brand name and their SEC affiliation, which automatically grants them a perceived schedule strength boost. But look at the actual opponents. Ole Miss plays in an SEC West that isn't what it was five years ago. They get Vanderbilt from the East. Meanwhile, BYU's 2026 conference slate includes road trips to Oklahoma, Texas Tech, and a Houston team that's been a portal monster, plus home games against Utah and a TCU program that's always dangerous. There is no breather. Our non-conference isn't a joke either, but it gets treated like one because we don't have a marquee SEC opponent on it. Since when is playing a solid Mountain West or American team a negative? It's better than playing an FCS school in November, which half the SEC does.
The entire system is designed to protect the old guard. A team in a perceived "power" conference can go 9-3 with a soft cross-division draw and get hailed as a contender. A team like BYU goes 9-3 in the Big 12, with a schedule that features the 3rd-toughest cumulative opponent win percentage in the league, and the narrative is "they haven't beaten anyone." Who exactly are we supposed to beat? BYU Cougars have to play everyone. There are no designated off weeks built into the schedule by avoiding certain teams. Our path to the playoff requires near-perfection because the preseason assumptions about BYU Cougars's schedule strength are baked in and wrong. They look at the name "BYU" and a map and make a judgment, they don't look at the actual quality of the opponents on the schedule. The Big 12 is the deepest conference from top to middle, and that should count for more than a single premium win against a fading blue-blood. Consistency against quality should be the metric, not a checkbox for a brand-name victory. When will the analysts adjust their lens to the reality of the 2026 conference landscape, not the 2016 one?
Just saw the 2026 recruiting rankings. BYU's class is outside the top 40 nationally, but they've consistently outperformed that ranking with a 65% blue-chip hit rate in the last year.
Why is the defensive scheme not getting more attention this spring? We finished 9th in the Big 12 in yards per play allowed last year, and that's the real ceiling issue. Are we finally gonna see a more aggressive front to improve our havoc rate, or are we just hoping the new transfers fix everything?