That comparison ignores how much the game has changed. Barker attempted 74 passes in his first two seasons, while Simpson has 35 attempts in a system that demands immediate readiness. Alabama's quarterback room is stacked with elite talent every year, so waiting three seasons isn't realistic anymore. The portal just reflects that modern roster math, not a lack of earning stripes. If a player like Simpson can get a better shot elsewhere, that's smart career management, not entitlement. His limited action last season still resulted in a 140.2 passer rating, which shows he's developed.